Can You Cook Shrooms? — Safety & Potency of Cooked Psilocybin Mushroom Explained

Ah, the culinary conundrum: can you cook shrooms? Picture this: you’re in your kitchen, spatula in hand, staring at a bundle of magic mushrooms like you’re the next contestant on “Chopped: Psychedelic Edition.” Your friend casually asks, “Can we sauté these for dinner, or are we about to ruin the vibe?”

You can cook shrooms, but it’s not as simple as tossing them in a pan like your usual button mushrooms. 

The real question is whether you’ll be turning those psilocybin-packed goodies into a gourmet delight or accidentally whipping up a dud that leaves you questioning all your life choices.

Spoiler: heat can degrade psilocybin, but it’s not a total buzzkill. The trick is knowing the right methods to keep the magic intact while still enjoying a tasty treat. 

Stick around, and we’ll explain the dos and don’ts of cooking with psychedelic mushrooms, so you don’t end up with a lukewarm trip or a meal that’s more meh than magical.

Can You Cook Shrooms: Key Takeaways

• Yes, you can cook magic mushrooms, but is it a good idea? Not really. Cooking in heat up to 25-150°C can degrade the potency of psilocybin mushrooms.
• If you don’t want to weaken their effects, stick to recipes with little or no heat, such as salad dressings. 
• Honestly, to keep things simple and get the full benefit, it’s better to eat shroom treats like chocolate bars or drink shroom tea. These also help mask that earthy taste better.

What You Should Know About Cooking Shrooms

Shrooms with Benefits

The next dimension in mind-body growth. Explore our thoughtfully crafted range; from Gummies and Capsules to Teas and Chocolates, designed to elevate clarity, creativity, and balance.

Shop Now

It’s really not a “good” versus “bad” verdict when it comes to cooking magic mushrooms. 

It boils down (no pun intended) to how much heat and how long for. 

There’s an online Q&A session in which Dr. K. Mandrake and Virginia Haze, authors of The Psilocybin Mushroom Bible, explain the interplay of preparing psilocybin mushrooms in heat. 

According to the experts, any potency degradation with short heating is minimal, and even with longer baking times, it doesn’t seem to affect it too badly, if at all.

So you can resolve to cook magic mushrooms. But you’ll have the issue of heat duration to worry about. 

How Long Can You Cook Shrooms For?

First, avoid cooking at high temperatures. If you add magic mushrooms to food, keep the cooking time under two hours and the temperature between 25 and 150 °C.

A study in the Journal of Chromatography found that psilocybin remains stable even when heated to 190°C (374°F) for a while. 

This means that common cooking methods like boiling or baking don’t always harm psilocybin, depending on how long they are cooked.

For example, muffins, cornbread, biscuits, and scones are typically baked between 93 and 96°C, while cakes and cupcakes are baked between 93 and 98°C. 

So, if you’re making these with magic mushrooms, you can be fairly confident that their potency will remain intact. 

Still, it’s a bit of a risk because you won’t know for sure until you try. That’s why, if you do cook with shrooms, it’s important to understand some cooking techniques.

Cooking Techniques for Magic Mushrooms

These techniques focus on the type of recipes you can use, the heating methods, and ways to hide the earthy taste of the mushrooms as you prepare them with food.

Your choice of recipe

Your recipes shouldn’t go near 25-150°C heating. Even when it does, it’s best to add the dried magic mushrooms into the cooking as late as possible. 

This technique is ideal if you’re preparing foods like pasta. 

If you’re making a pizza, cook the base first and then add the shrooms at a lower temperature for the final few minutes​ of preparation. 

Avoiding heat in food preparation 

Cooking without heat treatment is a great approach to preparing food with magic mushrooms. 

This is where options like shroom smoothies or combining shrooms with cold foods like salads or honey come to mind. 

It allows you to preserve the full potency of the magic mushrooms while improving taste.

The quantity of dried shrooms added while cooking

When eating psilocybin mushrooms with food, the effects can be milder, depending on how much you use. If you’re new to eating shrooms in food, start with a small dose. 

You can grind dried mushrooms into powder and mix them into your meal, just like you would with seasoning. 

Using the powder makes it easier to measure the right amount.

For example, if you’re making 100g of pasta for one person, you can use 500mg to 1g of dried mushrooms, grind them into powder, and add it to the dish. 

This will give you a mild but noticeable body high and some giddiness.

Quick Tip: 

• Many factors will ultimately determine how you feel after consuming food with mushrooms. But if it’s your first try, start with a small quantity. 
• Setting and setting (your state of mind and immediate surroundings) remain important when consuming shrooms, whether in raw or cooked form. 

How to Make Shrooms Taste Good

When cooking shrooms, there’ll be an interplay of flavors from the ingredients you’ve put into the food. So you won’t even have to worry about the shroom taste. 

But some food recipes do this better than others. For example, Energy Bites requires you to stir oats and chocolate chips with flax seed, peanut butter, honey, and vanilla extract in a bowl. 

The earthy taste will be completely hidden when you add dried magic mushroom powder to such a mix. 

Food recipes that require you to put in ingredients like herbs, butter, garlic, and lemon can also help to mask the shroom taste. 

Better Ways to Enjoy Shrooms Instead of Cooking

The best alternative method of consuming magic mushrooms depends on how much effort you will put into preparation.

We’ve tried all the trendy ways, and we can tell you that cooking shrooms is not the best way to enjoy them. 

Here are some of the top methods to consume shrooms and what each will do for your experience.

	Shroom teas	Shroom Chocolate Bars	Shroom-infused Capsules	Lemon Tekking
Kick-in time	30 minutes or quicker	It depends on dosage.	depends on dosage	15 to 45 minutes
Effect duration	1-4 hours for microdoses and 2–6 hours for high doses.	It depends on whether you take bites or half of the bar.	Depends on the quantity taken.	Lasting for 6 hours in total

1. Consume Shroom as Tea

Shroom tea is one of the best ways to enjoy magic mushrooms.

The main benefit of taking shroom tea is that it’s better for your stomach than eating raw mushrooms.

You can either commit to preparing it from the ground up or simply buy a shroom tea bag online. 

The high-quality shroom teas we offer at Schedule35 come in various flavors, including mango dragon fruit, strawberry lemonade, and floral peaches. 

We have a separate guide to teach you the step-by-step guide to making the perfect shroom tea and the proper dosage to achieve the desired effects. Read it HERE.

2. Consume Shroom in Chocolate Bars

Actual shroom chocolate bars have psilocybe cubensis as the main ingredient, making you trip. 

But it is also made of unsweetened chocolate, cocoa butter, whole milk powder, natural vanilla flavor, chocolate powder, coffee powder, and cream. 

The effects of magic mushroom chocolates are just like those of raw magic mushrooms—assuming your chocolate bar is the real deal.

Our catalog contains high-quality shroom-infused chocolate bars in various flavors, including Raspberry, Chocolate Hazelnut Crunch, and Crunchy Mocha, all under $65.

3. Consuming shrooms in Capsules

Another exciting way to consume shrooms is in capsules. This method is convenient if you’re into microdosing.

Due to the intricate process of preparing this one, we recommend purchasing the already-prepared shroom capsule. 

The high-quality shroom-infused capsules we offer at Schedule35 come in various potencies ranging from 500mg microdose to 2g superdose. 

4. Lemon Tekking

Lemon tekking is a fancy way of saying you soak your mushrooms in lemon juice before gulping them down. 

Psilocybin in shrooms needs to be converted into psilocin to make you trip. Usually, your stomach acid does this, but it takes time. 

Lemon juice mimics your stomach acid, speeding up the conversion and getting you to that psychedelic wonderland faster.

The biggest advantage of consuming your shroom the lemon way has to be that it plays down the nausea effect that shroom causes.

The citric acid in the lemon juice breaks down rigid shroom cell walls, reducing nausea.

Final Thoughts 

The bottom line is that each hod of consuming shrooms brings its own unique results. 

You can cook shrooms, but you don’t have to. The headache of heat precision, dosage concern, and choosing the food recipe itself is really not worth it. That’s our verdict. 

What do you think about cooking psilocybin mushrooms? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments.

Frequently Asked Questions